Skip to main content
LessonsCatch the Flaw

Lesson 19 · Science · Conservation of matter

Step 1 of 4

Find the wrong step

Ice melting inside a sealed container on a balance scale
Your lessonConservation of matterCore

The Ice-Cube Mass Mystery

A sealed container holds 100 grams of ice. The ice melts, but nothing can enter or leave.

Before
100 g of ice
Container
Sealed the whole time

Your question

What mass of water should remain inside after the ice melts?

Lumi’s answer: “About 80 grams, because solid ice loses mass when it becomes liquid.

1

Step 1 of 4

Find the wrong step

Find where the reasoning first breaks

Start with Step 1 and move downward. Choose the first line that stops making sense.

Later lines may be wrong too. Pick the first mistake.

Lumi’s work

These lines form one solution. Read them from top to bottom.

  1. 1

    The ice changes from solid water to liquid water.

  2. 2

    The container stays sealed while the ice melts.

  3. 3

    No water can enter or leave the container.

  4. 4

    Because the solid shape disappears, less than 100 grams remains.